That’s the question many viewers are asking.
With controversy swirling and emotions running high, the Netflix documentary revisiting America’s Next Top Model pulls back the curtain on what allegedly took place behind the scenes of one of reality television’s most influential franchises.
Tyra Banks, along with Jay Manuel, J. Alexander, Nigel Barker, and Ken Mok, participated in the documentary, offering their reflections on moments that shaped — and in some cases troubled — the series.
One of the most emotional segments centers around Shandi’s story, a heartbreaking reminder of how vulnerable many contestants were during filming.
Since the documentary’s release on Netflix, much of the public discourse has placed blame squarely on Banks. But is she the only one responsible?
Respectfully, in my opinion, she is not.
Tyra was the face of the franchise and an executive producer. However, television — especially in the early 2000s — was, and still is, a machine with layers of decision-makers. There were executives, producers, editors, and network powers above and alongside her who influenced what audiences ultimately saw. Every judge and producer present during that era played a role in shaping the environment.
That’s not to say Tyra is without fault. Accountability matters. But if we are going to examine the culture of that time, then the accountability must be shared.
It was the early 2000s — a period when reality television was rapidly evolving and boundaries were constantly being tested. Shows pushed limits for ratings. Contestants often signed up without fully understanding the emotional toll. In hindsight, many moments feel uncomfortable, even inappropriate. But hindsight also brings clarity that isn’t always available in real time.
There were numerous reality programs during that era that operated with similar — or arguably harsher — tactics. Yet the spotlight seems brightest on Tyra.
I’m not suggesting she should be given a pass. I am suggesting we allow space for growth. When you know better, you do better. And if this documentary serves as a cultural reckoning, perhaps it’s also an opportunity for grace — for everyone involved.
A full review is coming soon. In the meantime, for a deeper breakdown of the documentary, check out commentary from Kempire, who offers a thoughtful analysis of the broader context.
Photography: Netflix
